Society, Human Behaviour and Communities II: Normal and Abnormal Behaviour, the Life-Span Perspective with Developmental Tasks and Hazards, Psychoanalytic, Behavioural and Humanistic Theories of Personality, and Social Psychology from Perception and Attitudes to Collective Behaviour

This chapter takes the human-behaviour half of the second unit: normal and abnormal behaviour and its determinants; the life-span perspective of development, with the developmental tasks and hazards of each period from the prenatal stage to adulthood; the psychoanalytic, behavioural and humanistic theories of personality; and social psychology, from social perception and attitudes to communication and theories of collective behaviour. The syllabus's list of periods, prenatal, infancy, babyhood, childhood, puberty, adolescence and adulthood, is Elizabeth Hurlock's, and the chapter follows it. Each theory is read for what it gives the social worker: a way of understanding a client's behaviour and a direction for helping.

1. Normal and abnormal behaviour and its determinants

No single criterion separates normal from abnormal behaviour, and the standard approach combines several. Statistical infrequency treats behaviour far from the average as abnormal, but high intelligence is also rare. Violation of social norms treats behaviour that breaks cultural expectations as abnormal, but norms vary across cultures and change over time. Personal distress treats suffering as the mark, but some disorders involve little distress. Maladaptiveness or dysfunction asks whether behaviour prevents a person from meeting the demands of daily life. Marie Jahoda (1958) described positive mental health through six criteria: positive attitudes towards oneself, growth and self-actualisation, integration, autonomy, accurate perception of reality and environmental mastery. Many textbooks summarise the working test as the four Ds: deviance, distress, dysfunction and danger.

Behaviour is determined by the interaction of heredity and environment. Biological determinants include genetic inheritance, the nervous and endocrine systems and physical health; psychological determinants include learning, cognition, emotion and motivation; social determinants include family, peer group, school, culture, class, caste and gender. The biopsychosocial model, proposed by George Engel in 1977, holds that health and illness result from the interaction of all three, and it is the model on which social work assessment is built: a child's school refusal is examined for a medical cause, for anxiety or learning difficulty, and for bullying, family conflict or poverty, before any explanation is chosen.

⚠️ Abnormal is not the same as different
A question may offer "belonging to a minority group" or "holding unpopular opinions" as a criterion of abnormality. Neither is one. Treating difference as pathology is exactly what the norm-violation criterion risks, and it is why homosexuality was removed as a disorder from the DSM in 1973 and why social workers are trained to separate cultural difference from dysfunction.

2. The life-span perspective: developmental tasks and hazards

The life-span perspective, associated with Paul Baltes, holds that development is lifelong, multidimensional, multidirectional (gains and losses at every age), plastic and embedded in history and context. Elizabeth Hurlock's Developmental Psychology: A Life-Span Approach divides life into periods and, for each, describes its characteristics, developmental tasks and hazards, physical and psychological. The concept of developmental tasks is Robert Havighurst's (Developmental Tasks and Education, 1948): tasks that arise at a certain period, successful achievement of which leads to happiness and success with later tasks, while failure leads to unhappiness, social disapproval and difficulty later. They arise from physical maturation, cultural pressure and the individual's own values and aspirations.

Hurlock's periods, with tasks and hazards
Period (Hurlock)Approximate ageCharacteristic tasksTypical hazards
PrenatalConception to birthRapid growth; heredity fixed at conceptionMaternal malnutrition, infection, drugs and alcohol, stress, sex-selective practices
InfancyBirth to the end of the second weekAdjustment to life outside the wombLow birth weight, birth complications, neonatal infection
BabyhoodTwo weeks to two yearsWalking, solid food, beginnings of speech, attachmentMalnutrition, neglect, separation from caregivers
Early and late childhoodTwo to about eleven or twelveLanguage, self-care, school skills, peer relations, conscienceLearning difficulties, abuse, child labour, dropping out
PubertyAbout ten or twelve to thirteen or fourteenSexual maturation; acceptance of the changing bodyEarly or late maturing, poor body image, menstrual taboos
AdolescenceThirteen or fourteen to eighteenIdentity, emotional independence, preparation for work and relationshipsSubstance use, early marriage, risky behaviour, depression
AdulthoodEarly (18–40), middle (40–60), old age (60 onwards)Work, partnership, parenting, civic responsibility; later, adjusting to retirement and lossUnemployment, marital conflict, chronic illness, isolation
🧠 Infancy is two weeks long in Hurlock
In everyday speech infancy means the first year or two. In Hurlock's scheme, which the syllabus follows, infancy is only the period of the newborn, from birth to the end of the second week, and babyhood runs from then to the end of the second year. Questions built on Hurlock turn on exactly this distinction.

3. Theories of personality

Sigmund Freud's psychoanalytic theory describes a personality structure of id (the instinctual, pleasure-seeking part), ego (the realistic mediator, working on the reality principle) and superego (the internalised moral standards). Personality develops through psychosexual stages, oral, anal, phallic, latency and genital, and fixation at a stage leaves characteristic traits. The ego protects itself from anxiety by defence mechanisms: repression (pushing threatening material out of awareness), denial, projection (attributing one's own unacceptable impulses to others), displacement (redirecting feelings to a safer target), rationalisation, reaction formation (expressing the opposite of what is felt), regression and sublimation (channelling impulses into acceptable activity). Neo-Freudians revised the theory: Carl Jung proposed the collective unconscious and archetypes, and the attitudes of introversion and extraversion; Alfred Adler the inferiority complex, striving for superiority and the style of life; Erik Erikson eight psychosocial stages across the whole life.

Erikson's eight psychosocial stages
Erikson's stageApproximate periodVirtue if resolved
Trust versus mistrustFirst yearHope
Autonomy versus shame and doubtSecond and third yearsWill
Initiative versus guiltPreschoolPurpose
Industry versus inferioritySchool ageCompetence
Identity versus role confusionAdolescenceFidelity
Intimacy versus isolationEarly adulthoodLove
Generativity versus stagnationMiddle adulthoodCare
Integrity versus despairOld ageWisdom

Behavioural theories explain personality as learned behaviour. Ivan Pavlov showed classical conditioning, in which a neutral stimulus comes to evoke a response after pairing with one that naturally evokes it; John B. Watson founded behaviourism; B. F. Skinner showed operant conditioning, in which behaviour is shaped by its consequences, strengthened by reinforcement and weakened by punishment or extinction. Albert Bandura's social learning theory added observational learning, demonstrated in the Bobo doll experiments (1961), self-efficacy (1977) and reciprocal determinism among person, behaviour and environment. Humanistic theories stress growth and choice. Abraham Maslow's hierarchy of needs (1943) runs from physiological needs through safety, love and belonging and esteem to self-actualisation. Carl Rogers held that people have an actualising tendency, that distress arises from incongruence between the self-concept and experience, often created by conditions of worth, and that growth follows when a helper offers three core conditions: empathy, unconditional positive regard and congruence or genuineness.

🎯 Why each theory matters to a caseworker
Psychoanalytic theory gave the diagnostic school of casework its vocabulary, and defence mechanisms help a worker understand resistance, such as a parent who projects blame onto a teacher. Behavioural theory underlies behaviour modification with children and persons with intellectual disability, token economies and parent training. Rogers's core conditions are, in effect, the casework relationship: acceptance is unconditional positive regard, and empathy and genuineness are what make the relationship a helping one.

4. Social psychology: perception, attitudes and communication

Social perception is how people form impressions of others and explain their behaviour. Solomon Asch (1946) showed that central traits such as "warm" or "cold" shape the whole impression. Attribution theory, begun by Fritz Heider (1958), asks whether behaviour is attributed to internal, dispositional causes or external, situational ones; Harold Kelley's covariation model uses consensus, distinctiveness and consistency. The fundamental attribution error, named by Lee Ross (1977), is the tendency to overestimate dispositional and underestimate situational causes when explaining others' behaviour. For a social worker this is a professional hazard: attributing a family's poverty to laziness rather than to unemployment or debt is the fundamental attribution error at work, and it is also what the public often does to clients.

An attitude is a relatively enduring evaluation of an object with cognitive, affective and behavioural components. Attitudes are formed through direct experience, conditioning, observation and socialisation. Theories of attitude change include Leon Festinger's cognitive dissonance theory (1957), which holds that inconsistency between beliefs and behaviour creates discomfort that people reduce by changing one of them; Heider's balance theory; the Yale approach of Carl Hovland, which studied who says what to whom (source credibility, message and audience); and the elaboration likelihood model of Richard Petty and John Cacioppo (1986), with its central and peripheral routes to persuasion. Attitudes are measured by the Bogardus social distance scale (1925), the Thurstone scale of equal-appearing intervals (1928), the Likert summated rating scale (1932), Guttman's cumulative scale and Osgood's semantic differential (1957). Communication in social psychology concerns the transmission of meaning through verbal and non-verbal channels, the effects of source, message and channel, and barriers such as noise, perception and status differences, all of which bear on interviewing.

⚠️ Thurstone came before Likert
The order of the classic attitude scales is Bogardus (1925), Thurstone (1928), Likert (1932), Guttman (1944) and the semantic differential (1957). Thurstone's method needs judges to assign scale values to statements; Likert's simpler summated scale, which needs no judges, is why it became the most used.

5. Theories of collective behaviour

Collective behaviour is relatively spontaneous and unstructured behaviour of large numbers of people: crowds, mobs, panics, rumours, fads and the early stages of social movements. Gustave Le Bon's contagion theory (The Crowd, 1895) held that in a crowd individuals lose their rational selves and are swept by a "collective mind" through anonymity, contagion and suggestibility. Convergence theory, associated with Floyd Allport, reverses the direction: crowds form when people who already share dispositions come together, so the crowd expresses rather than creates their behaviour. Ralph Turner and Lewis Killian's emergent norm theory (1957) holds that crowds are not uniform; in an ambiguous situation new norms emerge through interaction, often led by a few, and define what is appropriate. Neil Smelser's value-added theory (Theory of Collective Behavior, 1962) lists six determinants, each necessary and adding value to the previous: structural conduciveness, structural strain, the growth and spread of a generalised belief, precipitating factors, mobilisation of participants for action, and the operation of social control.

ℹ️ From crowd to movement
Smelser's model bridges this unit and the social movements of Unit IV: structural strain and a generalised belief are where a movement's grievance and ideology begin, and mobilisation is where leadership and organisation come in. A community organiser who understands the determinants can help a group turn diffuse anger after a precipitating event, such as an eviction drive, into organised action rather than a riot.

Key takeaways

  • Abnormality is judged by combined criteria, statistical infrequency, norm violation, distress and dysfunction (the four Ds add danger); Jahoda (1958) listed six marks of positive mental health; Engel's biopsychosocial model (1977) is the basis of social work assessment.
  • Hurlock's periods: prenatal, infancy (birth to two weeks), babyhood (to two years), early and late childhood, puberty, adolescence and adulthood, each with tasks and hazards; developmental tasks are Havighurst's (1948), arising from maturation, cultural pressure and personal values.
  • Freud: id, ego, superego, five psychosexual stages and defence mechanisms; Jung, Adler and Erikson's eight psychosocial stages (identity versus role confusion in adolescence, integrity versus despair in old age).
  • Behavioural: Pavlov, Watson, Skinner, Bandura (observation, 1961; self-efficacy, 1977); humanistic: Maslow (1943) and Rogers's core conditions of empathy, unconditional positive regard and congruence, which mirror the casework relationship.
  • Social psychology: Asch's central traits (1946), attribution (Heider 1958, Kelley, the fundamental attribution error), dissonance (Festinger 1957), Hovland, ELM (1986), scales from Bogardus (1925) to Osgood (1957); collective behaviour: contagion (Le Bon 1895), convergence, emergent norm (Turner and Killian 1957), value-added (Smelser 1962, six determinants).

Practice questions (10)

Attempt each one before opening the answer. Every explanation names the tempting wrong option as well as the right one, because that is where marks are lost.

  1. In Elizabeth Hurlock's life-span scheme, "babyhood" refers to the period from:

    1. Birth to the end of the second week
    2. Conception to birth
    3. The end of the second week to the end of the second year
    4. Two years to six years
    Show answer

    Answer: C — The end of the second week to the end of the second year

    Hurlock's babyhood runs from the end of the second week to the end of the second year. Birth to two weeks is her "infancy", two to six years early childhood, and conception to birth the prenatal period.
  2. According to Erikson, the central psychosocial crisis of adolescence is:

    1. Intimacy versus isolation
    2. Industry versus inferiority
    3. Generativity versus stagnation
    4. Identity versus role confusion
    Show answer

    Answer: D — Identity versus role confusion

    Identity versus role confusion is the fifth stage, in adolescence, with fidelity as its virtue. Industry versus inferiority belongs to the school years, intimacy versus isolation to early adulthood and generativity versus stagnation to middle adulthood.
  3. How many psychosocial stages did Erik Erikson describe across the life span? Type the number.

    Numerical answer — type the value.

    Show answer

    Answer: 8

    Eight, from trust versus mistrust in the first year to integrity versus despair in old age. Freud's psychosexual stages, by contrast, number five and end with the genital stage in adolescence.
  4. Which of the following are among the six determinants in Neil Smelser's value-added theory of collective behaviour? Select all that apply.

    1. Precipitating factors
    2. A generalised belief
    3. An emergent norm defined by the crowd
    4. Structural strain
    Show answer

    Answer: A — Precipitating factors; B — A generalised belief; D — Structural strain

    Smelser's six are structural conduciveness, structural strain, a generalised belief, precipitating factors, mobilisation for action and social control. The emergent norm belongs to Turner and Killian's rival theory, not to Smelser's list.
  5. The theory that crowds develop new norms through interaction in ambiguous situations, rather than being swept by a collective mind, was proposed by:

    1. Ralph Turner and Lewis Killian
    2. Gustave Le Bon
    3. Floyd Allport
    4. Neil Smelser
    Show answer

    Answer: A — Ralph Turner and Lewis Killian

    Turner and Killian's emergent norm theory (1957) rejects the uniform crowd. Le Bon's contagion theory is the "collective mind" view it answers, Allport is associated with convergence and Smelser with the value-added model.
  6. Assertion (A): Bandura's social learning theory holds that behaviour can be learned by observing others, without the learner being directly reinforced. Reason (R): Skinner's operant conditioning holds that behaviour is shaped by its consequences. Choose the correct option.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: B — Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A

    Both statements are true, but the reason does not explain the assertion. Observational learning was Bandura's extension beyond operant conditioning: the Bobo doll children imitated aggression they had only watched, which consequence-based learning alone does not explain.
  7. The theory that inconsistency between beliefs and behaviour creates discomfort that people reduce by changing one of them is:

    1. Kelley's covariation model
    2. Asch's central trait theory
    3. Maslow's hierarchy of needs
    4. Festinger's cognitive dissonance theory
    Show answer

    Answer: D — Festinger's cognitive dissonance theory

    Leon Festinger set out cognitive dissonance in 1957. Kelley's model concerns how we attribute causes, Asch's work concerns impression formation, and Maslow's hierarchy concerns motivation.
  8. Which of the following are recognised criteria used in judging behaviour abnormal? Select all that apply.

    1. Personal distress
    2. Statistical infrequency
    3. Maladaptiveness or dysfunction in daily life
    4. Membership of a religious or cultural minority
    Show answer

    Answer: A — Personal distress; B — Statistical infrequency; C — Maladaptiveness or dysfunction in daily life

    Statistical infrequency, distress and dysfunction are standard criteria, used in combination because each alone fails. Belonging to a minority is not a criterion; treating cultural difference as abnormality is the misuse the norm-violation criterion invites.
  9. A man humiliated by his employer comes home and shouts at his children. Which defence mechanism does this illustrate?

    1. Sublimation
    2. Reaction formation
    3. Displacement
    4. Projection
    Show answer

    Answer: C — Displacement

    Displacement redirects feelings from a threatening target, the employer, to a safer one, the children. Projection attributes one's own impulses to others, sublimation channels them into acceptable activity, and reaction formation expresses the opposite feeling.
  10. The idea that developmental tasks arise from physical maturation, cultural pressure and the individual's own values, and that success with them leads to success with later tasks, is associated with:

    1. Jean Piaget
    2. Robert Havighurst
    3. Carl Rogers
    4. Alfred Adler
    Show answer

    Answer: B — Robert Havighurst

    Havighurst introduced developmental tasks in Developmental Tasks and Education (1948), and Hurlock built her life-span account on them. Piaget described cognitive stages, Rogers the self-concept and core conditions, and Adler the inferiority complex.