Information and Communication II: the Information Industry; IPR and Legal Issues; Plagiarism; the Right to Information Act and the Information Technology Act; and the National Knowledge Commission and the National Mission on Libraries

The second half of Unit I moves from what information is to the economy and law that surround it. This chapter covers items 6 to 10: the information industry and its generators, providers and intermediaries; intellectual property, its categories, the international conventions and treaties, and the Indian laws, read from the standpoint of a library that lends, copies and digitises; plagiarism, its concept and types, and the University Grants Commission's 2018 regulations; the Right to Information Act 2005 and the Information Technology Act 2000, as amended; and the two national bodies that shaped Indian library policy in this century, the National Knowledge Commission and the National Mission on Libraries. NET Law teaches intellectual property and cyber law as law; here the question is always what they mean for the collection, the user and the librarian.

1. The information industry: generators, providers and intermediaries

The information industry is the set of organisations that create, package, distribute and sell information products and services. The syllabus divides it into three groups. Generators create original information: researchers, universities, R&D laboratories, governments (census and statistics), authors and firms. Providers turn that raw output into saleable or usable products: publishers of books and journals, database producers, aggregators that bundle many publishers' content, and hosts that offer search on those databases. Intermediaries stand between providers and end users and add value by selecting, organising, searching and advising: libraries and information centres, information brokers and consultants, subscription agents and documentation centres. The boundaries blur online, where one company may publish journals, produce abstracting databases and sell analytics.

GroupExamplesValue added
GeneratorsCSIR laboratories, universities, the Office of the Registrar General (Census), authorsNew knowledge and primary data
ProvidersJournal and book publishers, database producers (abstracting and indexing services), aggregators and hostsEditing, peer review, packaging, indexing, search platforms
IntermediariesLibraries, information brokers, subscription agents, documentation centresSelection, organisation, expert searching, advice, access for those who cannot pay
🎯 Why libraries are called "intermediaries"
Search engines led some to predict "disintermediation", users going straight to sources. In practice libraries have moved to licensing, curation, discovery systems and information literacy: they still stand between an overwhelming supply and a user who needs the right item.

2. Intellectual property: categories, conventions, treaties and laws

Intellectual property rights are legal rights over creations of the mind, granted for a limited time so that creators can benefit while society eventually gains free use. The main categories are copyright and related (neighbouring) rights; patents; trademarks; industrial designs; geographical indications; layout designs of integrated circuits; protection of plant varieties; and undisclosed information (trade secrets). Copyright matters most to libraries because it covers books, articles, music, films, software and databases as compilations, and it arises automatically on creation without registration.

Convention or treatyYearScope
Paris Convention1883Industrial property: patents, marks, designs
Berne Convention1886Literary and artistic works; national treatment, automatic protection, minimum term of life plus 50 years
Universal Copyright Convention (UNESCO)1952A bridge for countries outside Berne; the © notice
Rome Convention1961Performers, producers of phonograms, broadcasters
WIPO Convention1967Created the World Intellectual Property Organization, Geneva; a UN specialised agency since 1974
TRIPS Agreement (WTO)1994, in force 1995Minimum standards for all IP categories, enforceable through WTO dispute settlement
WIPO Copyright Treaty and WPPT1996The "internet treaties": digital rights, technological protection measures
Marrakesh Treaty2013Exceptions for accessible-format copies for persons who are blind, visually impaired or otherwise print disabled; India was the first country to ratify it (2014)

India's laws follow these obligations. The Copyright Act 1957, amended most substantially in 2012, protects literary works for the author's life plus 60 years, sets out fair dealing for private use, research, criticism, review and reporting in section 52, permits libraries to make limited copies in section 52, and since 2012 allows accessible-format copies for persons with disabilities (section 52(1)(zb)). The Patents Act 1970 was amended in 1999, 2002 and 2005 (the 2005 amendment restored product patents for pharmaceuticals, as TRIPS required). Other statutes are the Trade Marks Act 1999, the Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act 1999, the Designs Act 2000, the Semiconductor Integrated Circuits Layout-Design Act 2000 and the Protection of Plant Varieties and Farmers' Rights Act 2001. The National IPR Policy was adopted in May 2016. Creative Commons (founded 2001; licences from 2002, current version 4.0) lets authors keep copyright while granting permissions in advance: BY (attribution), SA (share-alike), NC (non-commercial) and ND (no derivatives), and CC0 waives rights altogether.

⚠️ Copyright protects expression, not ideas
A theory, a fact or a method is free for anyone to use; copyright protects only the particular way it is expressed. Patents protect inventions (new, inventive and industrially applicable) for 20 years, and they require an application and examination, unlike copyright.

3. Plagiarism: concept and types

Plagiarism is presenting another person's words, ideas, data or work as one's own without due acknowledgement. It is an ethical offence in research and education even when no copyright is infringed (copying from a public-domain source without credit is still plagiarism), and it is distinct from copyright infringement, which can occur even with full credit. Libraries fight it through citation teaching, reference managers and similarity-checking software, and India's INFLIBNET runs the Shodh Shuddhi service (from 2019) that gives universities a plagiarism-detection tool.

TypeWhat happens
Direct or verbatimCopying text word for word without quotation marks or citation
Mosaic (patchwriting)Stitching phrases from several sources with a few words changed
Paraphrasing without creditRewording another's ideas but not citing them
Self-plagiarismReusing one's own published work as new: duplicate publication, "salami slicing" one study into many papers
Source-basedCiting sources wrongly or citing sources never read (secondary citation passed off as primary)
AccidentalCareless note-taking or poor citation skills, still plagiarism
Contract cheating (ghost-writing)Submitting work written by another person or service

The University Grants Commission (Promotion of Academic Integrity and Prevention of Plagiarism in Higher Educational Institutions) Regulations 2018 set graded levels for research work, based on similarity after excluding quotations, references, bibliography, common knowledge and generic terms: similarity up to 10 per cent is Level 0 (minor, no penalty); above 10 and up to 40 per cent is Level 1; above 40 and up to 60 per cent is Level 2; and above 60 per cent is Level 3. For a student's thesis the penalty rises from revising and resubmitting within a set period (Level 1), to being barred from resubmitting for a year (Level 2), to cancellation of the registration (Level 3); for teachers and researchers it rises from withdrawal of the manuscript to the withholding of annual increments and of the right to supervise research. The regulations also require institutions to teach research ethics and set up an Academic Integrity Panel.

🧠 Remember the UGC thresholds as 10, 40, 60
Up to 10: Level 0. Over 10 to 40: Level 1. Over 40 to 60: Level 2. Over 60: Level 3. A similarity score is not a verdict: a checker cannot tell a properly quoted passage from a copied one without a human reading the report.

4. The Right to Information Act and the Information Technology Act

The Right to Information Act 2005 came fully into force on 12 October 2005 and replaced the Freedom of Information Act 2002. It gives every citizen the right to information held by or under the control of a public authority. Section 4 requires public authorities to maintain records and publish information proactively; section 6 lets a citizen apply in writing or electronically, with a prescribed fee (₹10 under the central rules) and without giving reasons; section 7 requires a reply within 30 days, or 48 hours where the life or liberty of a person is involved; section 8 lists exemptions such as national security, cabinet papers, personal information and information that would impede an investigation; and sections 19 and 18 provide first appeals within the authority and second appeals and complaints to the Central or State Information Commission. Libraries are both users of the Act and, when they are public authorities, bound by it.

  • The Right to Information (Amendment) Act 2019 let the central government prescribe the term, salaries and conditions of service of the Chief Information Commissioner and Information Commissioners, which the Act had previously fixed; rules made in 2019 set the term at three years.
  • The Digital Personal Data Protection Act 2023, in section 44(3), amends section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act so that it exempts "information which relates to personal information", removing the clause's earlier test of larger public interest from that sub-section.

The Information Technology Act 2000, in force from 17 October 2000 and based on the UNCITRAL Model Law on Electronic Commerce (1996), gave legal recognition to electronic records and digital signatures, set up Certifying Authorities under a Controller, and defined cyber contraventions and offences. The Information Technology (Amendment) Act 2008, in force from 27 October 2009, broadened "digital signature" to technology-neutral "electronic signature", added data-protection duties for bodies corporate (section 43A), new offences such as identity theft, cheating by personation, violation of privacy and cyber terrorism (sections 66C to 66F), blocking powers (section 69A) and a safe harbour for intermediaries (section 79). The Supreme Court struck down section 66A (offensive messages) in Shreya Singhal v. Union of India (2015). The Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code Rules 2021 govern platforms, and the DPDP Act 2023 omits section 43A.

ℹ️ What this means for a library
An e-resource licence is a contract enforceable as an electronic record; user records in a library system are personal data; and a library that hosts user comments or a repository is an intermediary. Each of these brings legal duties the librarian must know.

5. The National Knowledge Commission and the National Mission on Libraries

The National Knowledge Commission was constituted on 13 June 2005 as a high-level advisory body to the Prime Minister, chaired by Sam Pitroda, to transform India into a knowledge society. It worked until 2009, organising its recommendations around five focus areas: access to knowledge, knowledge concepts (education), knowledge creation, knowledge application and the delivery of services. Libraries fell under access to knowledge, and a working group on libraries prepared its recommendations, later published as Libraries: Gateways to Knowledge. The central recommendations were to set up a National Commission on Libraries; prepare a national census of all libraries; revamp library and information science education and training; reassess staffing and professionalism; set up a central library fund; modernise library management with ICT and digitise collections; encourage community participation and public-private partnerships; and promote networking and resource sharing.

The National Mission on Libraries was set up by the Ministry of Culture in 2012, taking forward the Commission's recommendations, with the Raja Rammohun Roy Library Foundation (RRRLF) in Kolkata as its nodal agency. Its work has four components: the National Virtual Library of India (NVLI), a single portal to digital content from Indian libraries, archives and museums; the setting up of model libraries by upgrading selected national, state central and district libraries; a quantitative and qualitative survey of libraries to build a baseline; and capacity building of library staff through training.

FeatureNational Knowledge CommissionNational Mission on Libraries
Set up13 June 2005, advisory body to the Prime Minister2012, Ministry of Culture
NatureAdvisory: made recommendations across all knowledge sectorsImplementing: carries out library development
Key figure or agencyChair: Sam PitrodaNodal agency: RRRLF, Kolkata
Library outputsNational Commission on Libraries, census of libraries, LIS education reformNVLI, model libraries, survey, capacity building
⚠️ The Commission advised; the Mission implements
Questions sometimes attribute the NVLI to the National Knowledge Commission. The Commission recommended digitisation and networking; the NVLI is a component of the National Mission on Libraries, set up later under the Ministry of Culture.

Key takeaways

  • The information industry has generators (researchers, governments), providers (publishers, database producers, aggregators) and intermediaries (libraries, brokers, agents).
  • IPR conventions: Paris 1883, Berne 1886, UCC 1952, Rome 1961, WIPO 1967, TRIPS 1994, WCT and WPPT 1996, Marrakesh 2013 (India first to ratify); India's Copyright Act 1957 (amended 2012) gives life plus 60 years and section 52 exceptions.
  • Plagiarism is unacknowledged use of others' work; types include verbatim, mosaic, paraphrase, self-plagiarism and contract cheating; the UGC 2018 regulations set Levels 0 to 3 at 10, 40 and 60 per cent similarity.
  • RTI Act 2005 (in force 12 October 2005): 30 days, 48 hours for life and liberty, section 8 exemptions; amended 2019 on commissioners' terms; the DPDP Act 2023 rewrites section 8(1)(j). The IT Act 2000 was amended in 2008; section 66A fell in 2015.
  • The National Knowledge Commission (2005-2009, Sam Pitroda) recommended a National Commission on Libraries and a census of libraries; the National Mission on Libraries (2012, Ministry of Culture, RRRLF) runs the NVLI, model libraries, a survey and capacity building.

Practice questions (10)

Attempt each one before opening the answer. Every explanation names the tempting wrong option as well as the right one, because that is where marks are lost.

  1. Which international agreement, adopted in 2013, provides copyright exceptions for accessible-format copies for print-disabled persons?

    1. The Paris Convention
    2. The WIPO Performances and Phonograms Treaty
    3. The Rome Convention
    4. The Marrakesh Treaty
    Show answer

    Answer: D — The Marrakesh Treaty

    The Marrakesh Treaty (2013) facilitates access to published works for persons who are blind, visually impaired or otherwise print disabled, and India was the first country to ratify it. Rome (1961) covers performers and broadcasters, Paris (1883) industrial property, and the WPPT (1996) performers and phonograms online.
  2. Under the Right to Information Act 2005, within how many days must a Public Information Officer ordinarily reply to a request? Type the number.

    Numerical answer — type the value.

    Show answer

    Answer: 30

    Section 7(1) requires a decision within 30 days of receiving the request; where the information concerns the life or liberty of a person, it must be supplied within 48 hours.
  3. Under the UGC plagiarism regulations of 2018, a thesis showing similarity of 25 per cent, after the permitted exclusions, falls in:

    1. Level 1
    2. Level 0
    3. Level 3
    4. Level 2
    Show answer

    Answer: A — Level 1

    Similarity above 10 and up to 40 per cent is Level 1, which requires the researcher to revise and resubmit. Up to 10 per cent is Level 0, above 40 to 60 is Level 2, and above 60 is Level 3.
  4. Which of the following are Creative Commons licence elements? Select all that apply.

    1. BY (attribution)
    2. SA (share-alike)
    3. FD (fair dealing)
    4. NC (non-commercial)
    Show answer

    Answer: A — BY (attribution); B — SA (share-alike); D — NC (non-commercial)

    The four Creative Commons elements are BY, SA, NC and ND, combined into six licences, with CC0 as a public-domain waiver. Fair dealing is a statutory exception in copyright law, not a licence element.
  5. Who chaired the National Knowledge Commission constituted in 2005?

    1. S. R. Ranganathan
    2. M. S. Swaminathan
    3. Sam Pitroda
    4. D. S. Kothari
    Show answer

    Answer: C — Sam Pitroda

    Sam Pitroda chaired the Commission from 2005 to 2009. Ranganathan died in 1972, D. S. Kothari chaired the Education Commission of 1964-66, and M. S. Swaminathan led the National Commission on Farmers.
  6. Assertion (A): The National Virtual Library of India is a component of the National Mission on Libraries. Reason (R): The National Mission on Libraries was set up by the National Knowledge Commission in 2005. Choose the correct option.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: C — A is true, but R is false

    A is true and R is false. The NVLI is one of the Mission's four components, but the Mission was set up by the Ministry of Culture in 2012, following the Commission's recommendations; the Commission was an advisory body and set up no mission itself.
  7. Which section of the Information Technology Act was struck down by the Supreme Court in Shreya Singhal v. Union of India (2015)?

    1. Section 43A
    2. Section 66A
    3. Section 79
    4. Section 69A
    Show answer

    Answer: B — Section 66A

    Section 66A, which punished sending "offensive" messages, was held unconstitutional for vagueness and overbreadth. Section 69A (blocking) was upheld, section 79 (intermediary safe harbour) was read down, and section 43A was later omitted by the DPDP Act 2023.
  8. Which of the following are instances of plagiarism even if no copyright is infringed? Select all that apply.

    1. Quoting a sentence in quotation marks with full citation
    2. Summarising a theory in one's own words and citing its author
    3. Copying a passage from a public-domain book without citing it
    4. Republishing one's own earlier paper as a new one
    Show answer

    Answer: C — Copying a passage from a public-domain book without citing it; D — Republishing one's own earlier paper as a new one

    Plagiarism is about credit, not ownership: copying a public-domain text without citation and duplicate publication of one's own work are both plagiarism. A properly quoted and cited sentence, or a cited summary, is legitimate scholarly use.
  9. Under the Copyright Act 1957, for how many years after the author's death does copyright in a published literary work last? Type the number.

    Numerical answer — type the value.

    Show answer

    Answer: 60

    India protects literary, dramatic, musical and artistic works for the author's lifetime plus 60 years, counted from the beginning of the calendar year after death. The Berne minimum is life plus 50 years.
  10. In the information industry, a library that selects, organises and helps users search licensed databases acts chiefly as a:

    1. Intermediary
    2. Generator
    3. Database producer
    4. Aggregator
    Show answer

    Answer: A — Intermediary

    Libraries are intermediaries between providers and end users, adding value by selection, organisation, searching and advice. Generators create original information, and database producers and aggregators are providers.