Social Institutions, and Social Change and Processes
2. Institutions II: religion, education, and law and customs
| Institution | Functionalist reading | Conflict or critical reading |
|---|---|---|
| Religion | Durkheim: integrates society around the sacred; Malinowski: relieves anxiety at crises of life | Marx: 'the opium of the people', legitimating inequality; Weber adds that religion can also drive change |
| Education | Durkheim: the methodical socialisation of the young generation; Parsons: the school allocates roles by achievement | Bowles and Gintis: the correspondence principle — school mirrors the workplace hierarchy; Bourdieu: cultural reproduction |
| Law and customs | Durkheim: repressive law with mechanical, restitutive with organic solidarity | Marxist and critical legal studies: law as an instrument or expression of dominant interests |
On law, Henry Maine's Ancient Law (1861) proposed that 'the movement of progressive societies has hitherto been a movement from status to contract' — from positions fixed by family and birth to relations freely entered by individuals. Customs are norms sanctioned by long usage and community opinion; legal pluralism describes the coexistence of state law with customary, religious and community legal orders, which is the everyday reality of India's personal laws, caste panchayats and tribal customary law in Sixth Schedule areas.
3. Evolution and diffusion; modernization and development
Evolutionism explained change as the passage of all societies through the same stages. Comte's law of three stages, Herbert Spencer's movement from simple to compound societies and from militant to industrial types (and his phrase 'survival of the fittest'), and Lewis Henry Morgan's Ancient Society (1877), with its sequence of savagery, barbarism and civilisation, are the classic unilinear schemes. Julian Steward later proposed multilinear evolution, in which similar ecological conditions produce parallel sequences. Diffusionism replied that most culture traits spread by borrowing rather than being independently invented. The British school (Grafton Elliot Smith, W.J. Perry) derived civilisation from ancient Egypt; the German-Austrian Kulturkreis school (Fritz Graebner, Wilhelm Schmidt) traced 'culture circles'; the American school (Franz Boas, Clark Wissler) mapped culture areas.
Modernization theory (1950s–60s) cast change as a movement from tradition to modernity along Parsons's pattern variables: Daniel Lerner's The Passing of Traditional Society (1958) stressed empathy and media exposure, and W.W. Rostow's five stages of growth ran from traditional society to high mass consumption. Its critics argued that underdevelopment was produced, not merely left over: dependency theory (André Gunder Frank's 'development of underdevelopment') located it in the metropolis-satellite relations of world capitalism, and Immanuel Wallerstein's world-systems theory divided the world economy into core, semi-periphery and periphery. Amartya Sen (Development as Freedom, 1999) redefined development as the expansion of human capabilities. In India, Yogendra Singh's Modernization of Indian Tradition (1973) analysed change along orthogenetic and heterogenetic sources at cultural and structural levels, and the Rudolphs' The Modernity of Tradition (1967) showed caste associations and traditional forms adapting to serve modern democratic ends.
4. Social transformations and globalization; social mobility
- Arjun Appadurai (Modernity at Large, 1996): global cultural flows move through five 'scapes' — ethnoscapes (people), mediascapes (images), technoscapes (technology), financescapes (capital) and ideoscapes (ideas) — which are disjunctive, not synchronised.
- Roland Robertson: glocalization — global products and ideas are adapted to local contexts, so globalization produces heterogeneity as well as sameness.
- George Ritzer (The McDonaldization of Society, 1993): the principles of the fast-food restaurant — efficiency, calculability, predictability and control — spread through ever more sectors, a contemporary version of Weber's rationalisation.
- Giddens (time-space distanciation) and Harvey (time-space compression) theorise the shrinking of distance that makes these flows possible.
Social mobility is movement of individuals or groups between positions in a system of stratification. Pitirim Sorokin (Social Mobility, 1927) distinguished vertical mobility (up or down the hierarchy) from horizontal mobility (a change of position at the same level). Mobility is intergenerational (comparing children with parents) or intragenerational (within one career). Structural mobility results from changes in the occupational structure itself — the expansion of white-collar jobs pulls people up — while exchange (circulation) mobility is movement that would occur even if the structure stayed the same. Blau and Duncan's The American Occupational Structure (1967) modelled status attainment — how father's status, education and first job shape a person's occupational status. In India, group mobility through Sanskritisation and individual mobility through education and reservation run side by side.
Key takeaways
- Murdock's universal nuclear family with four functions is the functionalist baseline for marriage, family and kinship; descent, affinity, residence and marriage rules classify kinship systems.
- Polanyi's embeddedness, Weber's state as monopoly of legitimate force, and Fortes and Evans-Pritchard's stateless segmentary societies define economy and polity as institutions.
- Religion, education and law each have a functionalist reading (integration, socialisation, solidarity) and a critical one (ideology, correspondence and reproduction, dominant interests); Maine saw law moving from status to contract.
- Unilinear evolution (Comte, Spencer, Morgan) gave way to multilinear evolution and diffusionism; modernization theory was challenged by dependency and world-systems theory and by Sen's capability approach.
- Globalization is theorised through Appadurai's scapes, Robertson's glocalization and Ritzer's McDonaldization; Sorokin's vertical and horizontal mobility and the structural-exchange distinction organise the study of mobility.
Practice questions (10)
Attempt each one before opening the answer. Every explanation names the tempting wrong option as well as the right one, because that is where marks are lost.
Which four functions did Murdock attribute to the nuclear family?
Show answer
Answer: A — Sexual, reproductive, economic and educational
Murdock's Social Structure (1949) named sexual, reproductive, economic and educational functions. AGIL is Parsons's scheme for any social system.Polanyi's argument that in pre-market societies economic activity is submerged in kinship, religion and politics is expressed by the concept of:
Show answer
Answer: B — Embeddedness
Embeddedness is Polanyi's central idea in The Great Transformation; the market society's attempt to disembed the economy produced a countermovement for social protection.'The movement of progressive societies has hitherto been a movement from status to contract.' Who wrote this?
Show answer
Answer: C — Henry Maine
The sentence is from Maine's Ancient Law (1861). Durkheim's parallel contrast is mechanical versus organic solidarity; Tönnies's is Gemeinschaft versus Gesellschaft; Spencer's is militant versus industrial society.Bowles and Gintis's 'correspondence principle' holds that:
Show answer
Answer: D — The social relations of schooling mirror those of capitalist work
In Schooling in Capitalist America (1976) Bowles and Gintis argued that the hierarchy, discipline and extrinsic rewards of school prepare pupils for the hierarchy of the workplace — a Marxist reading of education.Lewis Henry Morgan's Ancient Society arranged human history in which sequence?
Show answer
Answer: B — Savagery, barbarism, civilisation
Morgan's scheme (1877) runs from savagery through barbarism to civilisation, each subdivided by technological markers. The other sequences belong to Comte, Spencer and Rostow.Which of the following are among Appadurai's five dimensions of global cultural flow? Select all that apply.
Show answer
Answer: A — Ideoscapes; C — Ethnoscapes; D — Financescapes
Appadurai's five are ethnoscapes, mediascapes, technoscapes, financescapes and ideoscapes. 'Kinscapes' is not among them.The 'development of underdevelopment' is a thesis of:
Show answer
Answer: B — André Gunder Frank
Frank, a dependency theorist, argued that satellite regions were actively underdeveloped by their incorporation into the capitalist world system, contradicting the modernization view of Rostow, Lerner and Parsons.A large part of the upward mobility of the children of farmers into office jobs occurred because the number of office jobs expanded. This is:
Show answer
Answer: C — Structural mobility
Mobility produced by a change in the occupational structure itself — more positions at higher levels — is structural mobility; exchange mobility is the reshuffling that would occur even with an unchanged structure.Which term did Roland Robertson use for the adaptation of global products and ideas to local conditions?
Numerical answer — type the value.
Show answer
Answer: glocalization
Glocalization blends global and local: it captures how globalization produces local variants rather than simple homogenisation, a counterweight to Ritzer's McDonaldization thesis.Assertion (A): Yogendra Singh analysed the modernization of Indian tradition at both cultural and structural levels. Reason (R): He distinguished orthogenetic (internal) from heterogenetic (external) sources of change. Choose the correct option.
Show answer
Answer: B — Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
Both statements describe Singh's framework, which crossed two axes — level (cultural and structural) and source (orthogenetic and heterogenetic). The source distinction does not explain why he worked at two levels; they are independent axes of the same scheme.