Sales Force and Personal Selling, Service Marketing, Customer Relationship Marketing, Retail Marketing, Emerging Trends and International Marketing
2. Service marketing: managing service quality and brands, strategies of service firms; customer relationship marketing
A service is any act or performance one party can offer another that is essentially intangible and does not result in ownership of anything; offerings run from pure tangible goods through goods with accompanying services, hybrids and services with accompanying goods to pure services. Their four characteristics — intangibility, inseparability, variability (heterogeneity) and perishability — dictate the marketing responses: tangibilise the intangible through evidence and image, manage the provider-customer interface through training and multi-site strategies, standardise through good hiring, procedures and monitoring, and match capacity to demand through differential pricing, reservations, complementary services, part-time staff and shared capacity. The services marketing mix adds people, process and physical evidence to the four Ps (Booms and Bitner, 1981), and service marketing is threefold — external (firm to customer: promise), internal (firm to employees: enabling the promise) and interactive (employee to customer: keeping the promise) — Grönroos's triangle. Managing service quality follows the gaps model of Parasuraman, Zeithaml and Berry (1985): five gaps between customer expectation and management perception, management perception and quality specification, specification and delivery, delivery and external communication, and — their sum — expected and perceived service; SERVQUAL measures the last on five determinants — reliability, assurance, tangibles, empathy, responsiveness (RATER) — of which reliability matters most. Service-quality practices: strategic concept, top-management commitment, high standards, self-service technologies, monitoring (comparison shopping, ghost shopping, surveys), satisfying complaints and recovery (the recovery paradox), and satisfying employees along with customers — Heskett's service-profit chain. Managing service brands means differentiating the offering (primary and secondary service features, innovation), delivery (people, environment, process) and image (symbols and branding), and building brand equity where the brand is often the company itself. The strategies of service firms are differentiation, quality leadership, productivity improvement (better-trained staff, quantity for quality, industrialising the service — Levitt, designing more effective services, incentives for customer self-service, technology), and customer-centric strategies such as the flower of service (Lovelock — eight supplementary services: information, consultation, order-taking, hospitality, safekeeping, exceptions, billing, payment), service blueprinting (Shostack), yield management and the service-dominant logic.
| Aspect | Content | Names and points |
|---|---|---|
| Concept | Relationship marketing attracts, maintains and enhances customer relationships (Berry, 1983) — a shift from transaction marketing (single sale, product features, short horizon, little service, limited commitment) to relationship marketing (retention, customer value, long horizon, high service, high commitment, quality as everyone's concern); the Nordic school (Grönroos, Gummesson) and the IMP group | Trust and commitment are the key mediating variables (Morgan and Hunt, 1994); retention economics — it costs several times more to win a customer than to keep one, and a small rise in retention lifts profit disproportionately (Reichheld) |
| Relationship building and the loyalty ladder | Prospect, customer, client, supporter, advocate, partner (Christopher, Payne and Ballantyne); Kotler's levels of relationship marketing — basic, reactive, accountable, proactive, partnership — chosen by the number of customers and the margin | Few customers and high margin justify partnership marketing; many customers and low margin get basic or reactive |
| Strategies | Financial bonds (frequency and loyalty programmes, volume pricing), social bonds (personal relationships, community, events), customisation bonds (mass customisation, anticipation), structural bonds (integrated systems, shared processes) — Berry and Parasuraman's four levels; cross-selling and up-selling; win-back; customer tiering (platinum, gold, iron, lead — the customer pyramid of Zeithaml, Rust and Lemon) | Structural bonds are the hardest for competitors to break |
| Values | Customer lifetime value as the guiding metric; value for the customer (the relationship's benefits over its costs) and value from the customer (revenue, referrals, information, co-creation); customer equity as the sum of CLVs | CLV = present value of (margin × retention probability) over the expected life, less acquisition cost |
| CRM process and systems | Peppers and Rogers' IDIC — identify customers, differentiate them by value and needs, interact with them, customise the offering; the CRM cycle — acquire, retain, grow; systems — operational (sales-force automation, marketing automation, service automation), analytical (data warehouse, mining, segmentation, churn prediction), collaborative (channels, partners); Payne and Frow's strategic CRM framework; permission marketing (Godin) and one-to-one marketing | CRM is a strategy enabled by technology, not the software alone — most failures are of process and culture; privacy law (India's Digital Personal Data Protection Act 2023) constrains data use |
3. Retail marketing: trends in India and types of outlets; emerging trends — e-marketing, direct, digital and green marketing
| Type | Description | Indian example |
|---|---|---|
| Specialty store | Narrow product line with deep assortment — single-line, limited-line, super-specialty | Bata, Tanishq, Croma |
| Department store | Several product lines, each run as a separate department by buyers or merchandisers | Shoppers Stop, Lifestyle, Westside |
| Supermarket | Large, low-cost, low-margin, high-volume self-service store for food and household needs | More, Reliance Fresh, Spencer's |
| Hypermarket and superstore | Very large selling area combining supermarket, discount and warehouse retailing under one roof | Big Bazaar (now defunct), Reliance Smart, DMart |
| Convenience store | Small, near residences, long hours, limited high-turnover lines at slightly higher prices | The kirana store — India's dominant format — and 24Seven |
| Discount store and off-price retailer | Standard merchandise at lower prices on lower margins and higher volume; off-price sells surplus, irregulars and overruns — factory outlets, independents, warehouse clubs | DMart, Vishal Mega Mart, Brand Factory |
| Category killer | Giant specialty store with a very deep assortment in one category at low prices | Decathlon, IKEA |
| Non-store retailing | Direct selling (one-to-one, party plan, multi-level marketing), direct marketing (catalogue, telemarketing, TV shopping, e-commerce), automatic vending, buying services | Amway, Flipkart, Amazon India, Nykaa |
| Corporate retailing | Corporate chain stores, voluntary chains, retailer cooperatives, consumer cooperatives, franchise organisations, merchandising conglomerates; shopping centres — malls, community and neighbourhood centres | Reliance Retail, Tata's Trent, Kendriya Bhandar (cooperative) |
Retailing includes all activities in selling goods or services directly to final consumers for personal, non-business use. Its theories are the wheel of retailing (McNair — new formats enter as low-price, low-margin operations, trade up, and are displaced by the next low-price entrant), the retail accordion (alternation between wide and narrow assortments), the retail life cycle (innovation, accelerated development, maturity, decline) and the dialectic process. Retail marketing decisions are target market, product assortment and procurement (category management, private labels), services and store atmosphere, price (high mark-up low volume or the reverse; everyday low pricing), communications and location (central business districts, regional shopping centres, community centres, strip malls, a location within a larger store, and stand-alone). Recent trends in India: the growth of organised retail alongside the still-dominant kirana; the rise of e-commerce marketplaces (Flipkart, Amazon) and vertical players, and of quick commerce (Blinkit, Zepto, Swiggy Instamart) with ten-minute grocery delivery; omnichannel and phygital retail; the Open Network for Digital Commerce (ONDC, 2021) as a government-backed interoperable network; the Unified Payments Interface making digital payment the default; private labels and value formats; the FDI policy allowing 100% in single-brand retail (automatic route, with local-sourcing conditions) and 51% in multi-brand retail with government approval, while the e-commerce policy permits 100% FDI only in the marketplace model, not inventory-based retail; the Consumer Protection Act 2019 and its e-commerce rules; social commerce and influencer-led selling; and the consolidation of large groups (Reliance Retail, Tata Digital) buying formats and brands.
| Trend | Concept | Tools and terms |
|---|---|---|
| E-marketing (internet or online marketing) | Marketing through the internet and electronic channels — the firm's website, e-mail, online advertising, e-commerce; part of e-business (Kotler: e-marketing is the e-business side that markets and sells online) | B2C, B2B, C2C, C2B; click-only versus brick-and-click; the 4 Cs of online marketing (Kotler) — context, content, community, customisation, plus communication, connection, commerce; interactivity and disintermediation |
| Direct marketing | The use of consumer-direct channels to reach and deliver goods and services to customers without marketing middlemen, seeking a measurable response or transaction | Direct mail, catalogue, telemarketing, direct-response TV, kiosks, e-mail, mobile; the customer database and database marketing; RFM analysis (recency, frequency, monetary value); Direct Marketing Association; legal limits — do-not-call registry (TRAI's National Customer Preference Register) |
| Digital marketing | Marketing through digital technologies and data — the broader successor of e-marketing that includes mobile, social, search and programmatic channels and measures every touch | Search engine optimisation and marketing (organic and paid search), display and programmatic advertising, social-media marketing, content marketing, influencer marketing, affiliate marketing, e-mail and marketing automation, video and short-form, app and mobile marketing; owned, paid and earned media; metrics — impressions, click-through rate, cost per click and per acquisition, conversion rate, return on ad spend, engagement, bounce rate; the customer journey and the 'moments of truth'; AI-driven personalisation and chatbots |
| Green marketing | Marketing products presumed to be environmentally safe — modifying the product, production process, packaging and advertising to reduce environmental impact (Polonsky; the AMA's definition covers all three of retailing, social and environmental senses) | Green consumers and segments; the green marketing mix; eco-labels (India's Ecomark 1991, BEE star rating, Energy Star); greenwashing and its regulation (the Central Consumer Protection Authority's 2024 guidelines on greenwashing claims); life-cycle assessment; circular economy and extended producer responsibility; sustainability marketing and the triple bottom line |
4. International marketing: entry mode decisions and planning the marketing mix for international markets
International marketing is the performance of marketing activities across national boundaries; global marketing treats the world as one market. The decisions run in sequence: whether to go abroad (pull of larger markets, push of a saturated home market, following customers, counter-attacking competitors), which markets to enter (few or many — the waterfall versus sprinkler approach; developed or developing; regional clusters — the EPRG orientation of Perlmutter and the psychic-distance principle), how to enter, what marketing programme to run and how to organise. The five entry modes rise in commitment, risk, control and profit potential: indirect exporting (through home-country export houses, agents, cooperative organisations or export-management companies — least investment), direct exporting (own export department, overseas sales branch, travelling representatives, foreign distributors or agents), licensing (a licensee pays fees or royalties for the use of a process, trademark, patent or know-how — low risk, low control; management contracts, contract manufacturing and franchising are its variants), joint ventures (shared ownership and control with a local partner — needed where law, capital or knowledge requires it) and direct investment (a wholly owned assembly or manufacturing subsidiary, greenfield or by acquisition — full control and the largest exposure to currency, expropriation and market risk). Strategic alliances, turnkey projects and piggybacking are the other named routes; Dunning's eclectic (OLI) paradigm — ownership, location and internalisation advantages — explains when direct investment is chosen, and the Uppsala model describes the incremental progression through the modes.
| Element | Standardise or adapt | Strategies and terms |
|---|---|---|
| The central debate | Levitt's 'The Globalization of Markets' (1983) argued for standardised global products and brands on scale economies and converging tastes; the adaptation view stresses cultural, legal, economic and usage differences; the resolution is 'glocalisation' — think global, act local — standardising the core and adapting the periphery | Standardisation cuts cost and builds a global brand; adaptation fits the market and costs more; most firms mix the two |
| Product and communication | Keegan's five strategies: straight extension (same product, same message — Coca-Cola), product adaptation (change the product, same message — McDonald's menu in India), communication adaptation (same product, new message), dual adaptation (change both) and product invention (backward invention — reintroducing earlier forms; forward invention — a new product for the market's needs) | Country-of-origin effects, global brands versus local brands, brand-name translation problems, packaging and labelling law, standards and certification |
| Price | Uniform price everywhere, market-based price in each country, or cost-based price in each country; price escalation from freight, tariffs, margins and currency; transfer pricing between subsidiaries; dumping (selling below home price or cost — met by anti-dumping duties under WTO rules); grey markets and parallel imports; counterfeit goods | Incoterms fix who bears freight and insurance; currency choice and hedging; penetration pricing in emerging markets — the 'bottom of the pyramid' (Prahalad) and reverse innovation |
| Place (distribution) | The whole-channel view — seller's headquarters organisation, channels between nations (entry mode, intermediaries, transport), channels within nations (local wholesalers and retailers, which differ hugely: Japan's multi-layered system, India's kirana network); adapt to local channel structure | Global retailing and e-commerce cross-border selling change the calculus; logistics and Incoterms |
| Promotion | Global campaign themes with local execution; media availability and regulation differ (advertising to children, comparative claims, alcohol and tobacco); language, colour and symbol meanings; personal selling norms; sales promotion legality varies | Hofstede's dimensions and Hall's high- and low-context cultures decide message style; global agencies versus local agencies |
| Organisation | Export department, international division (geographic, product or functional), and the global organisation (Bartlett and Ghoshal's multinational, global, international and transnational forms) | The transnational combines global efficiency, local responsiveness and worldwide learning |
Key takeaways
- Sales force structures are territorial, product, market and complex; size by the workload method is total annual calls needed divided by calls per representative; the selling process runs prospecting, pre-approach, approach, presentation, objections, closing, follow-up.
- Services are intangible, inseparable, variable and perishable; the mix adds people, process and physical evidence; the gaps model has five gaps and SERVQUAL five RATER dimensions with reliability first; service marketing is external, internal and interactive.
- Relationship marketing is Berry's 1983 term; the loyalty ladder climbs prospect to partner; bonds are financial, social, customisation and structural; CRM's IDIC is identify, differentiate, interact, customise, and its systems are operational, analytical and collaborative.
- Retail formats run specialty, department, supermarket, hypermarket, convenience, discount, category killer and non-store; the wheel of retailing is McNair's; India's trends are organised retail beside kirana, e-commerce and quick commerce, ONDC, and FDI at 100% single-brand and 51% multi-brand with marketplace-only e-commerce.
- Direct marketing seeks a measurable response without middlemen; digital marketing spans search, social, content, influencer and programmatic with CTR, CPA and ROAS as metrics; green marketing is opposed by greenwashing; entry modes rank indirect export, direct export, licensing, joint venture, direct investment, and Keegan's five product-communication strategies decide adaptation.
Practice questions (10)
Attempt each one before opening the answer. Every explanation names the tempting wrong option as well as the right one, because that is where marks are lost.
A firm has 200 large accounts needing 24 sales calls a year and 800 small accounts needing 6. If a representative can make 800 calls a year, the workload method gives a sales force of:
Show answer
Answer: A — 12 representatives
Total workload = 200 × 24 + 800 × 6 = 9,600 calls; 9,600 ÷ 800 = 12. The workload (build-up) approach sizes the force from required call frequency by account class.In the personal selling process, the step that immediately follows the presentation and demonstration is:
Show answer
Answer: A — Overcoming objections
The sequence is prospecting and qualifying, pre-approach, approach, presentation and demonstration, overcoming objections, closing, follow-up and maintenance. Objections arise in response to the presentation and must be handled before the close.In the gaps model of service quality, the gap between what the firm's advertising promises and what its service actually delivers is the gap between:
Show answer
Answer: A — Service delivery and external communications
Gap 4 in Parasuraman, Zeithaml and Berry's model: over-promising in communications inflates expectations and lowers perceived quality. Gaps 1 to 3 are the knowledge, standards and performance gaps; gap 5, the customer gap, is their result.Grönroos's 'internal marketing' in service firms refers to:
Show answer
Answer: A — Training and motivating employees to serve customers well — enabling the promise made to customers
The services marketing triangle: external marketing makes the promise, internal marketing enables it by preparing employees, and interactive marketing keeps it at the moment of service. Berry called employees the first market of a service firm.Peppers and Rogers' IDIC framework for customer relationship management stands for:
Show answer
Answer: A — Identify, differentiate, interact, customise
One-to-one marketing identifies individual customers, differentiates them by value and needs, interacts to learn more, and customises the offer — the process behind operational and analytical CRM systems.McNair's 'wheel of retailing' hypothesis states that:
Show answer
Answer: A — New retail formats enter as low-price, low-margin operations, gradually trade up, and are displaced by the next low-price entrant
The wheel explains why department stores were undercut by discount stores and they in turn by warehouse clubs and online sellers. The assortment alternation is the retail accordion, and the stage sequence is the retail life cycle.Under India's FDI policy for retail, foreign direct investment is permitted in e-commerce only in the:
Show answer
Answer: A — Marketplace model, not the inventory-based model
A marketplace is a technology platform connecting buyers and sellers, where 100% FDI is allowed; an inventory-based e-commerce entity owns the goods it sells, which is multi-brand retail and closed to FDI. Single-brand physical retail allows 100%, multi-brand 51% with government approval.Direct marketing is distinguished from other promotion tools chiefly by its:
Show answer
Answer: A — Use of consumer-direct channels to obtain a measurable response or transaction without intermediaries
Direct mail, catalogues, telemarketing, direct-response TV and e-mail built on a customer database seek an immediate, measurable response. Mass-media awareness is advertising, unpaid coverage is publicity, and face-to-face negotiation is personal selling.Among the modes of entering a foreign market, the one with the lowest investment, risk and control is:
Show answer
Answer: A — Indirect exporting
The modes rise in commitment, risk, control and profit potential from indirect exporting through direct exporting, licensing and joint ventures to direct investment. Indirect exporting through home-country export houses needs no overseas presence or investment at all.In Keegan's international product and communication strategies, selling the same product abroad with a different advertising message is:
Show answer
Answer: A — Communication adaptation
Straight extension changes neither product nor message, product adaptation changes the product only, communication adaptation the message only, dual adaptation both, and product invention creates a new product for the market.