Culture, Diversity, Stress and Justice; HRM Concept, Planning, Staffing, Training, Job Analysis and Compensation
2. Emotions and stress management; organisational justice and whistle blowing
Emotions are intense, short-lived feelings directed at someone or something; moods are less intense and diffuse; affect covers both. Emotional labour (Hochschild) is the display of organisationally desired emotions, with surface acting (faking) and deep acting (trying to feel), and emotional dissonance is the gap between felt and displayed. Emotional intelligence — Salovey and Mayer's four branches (perceiving, using, understanding, managing emotions) and Goleman's five components (self-awareness, self-regulation, motivation, empathy, social skills) — predicts leadership and service performance. Affective events theory (Weiss and Cropanzano) links workplace events to emotions to attitudes and behaviour. Stress is an adaptive response to a demand (stressor) that exceeds the person's resources, and Hans Selye's general adaptation syndrome runs alarm, resistance, exhaustion. Stressors are environmental (economic, political, technological), organisational (task, role — ambiguity, conflict, overload — interpersonal, structure, leadership) and personal (family, finance, personality); Type A personality and an external locus of control heighten vulnerability. Eustress is the positive, energising form; distress the harmful one, and the Yerkes-Dodson inverted U says moderate stress raises performance while too little or too much lowers it. Consequences are physiological, psychological (burnout — Maslach's emotional exhaustion, depersonalisation, reduced accomplishment) and behavioural (absenteeism, turnover, accidents). Management is individual — time management, exercise, relaxation, meditation and yoga, social support, cognitive restructuring — and organisational — selection and placement, realistic goals, job redesign, participation, communication, sabbaticals, wellness and employee assistance programmes.
| Concept | Meaning | Names, law and institutions |
|---|---|---|
| Distributive justice | Perceived fairness of outcomes — pay, promotion — judged by equity, equality or need | Adams's equity theory is its root; Homans |
| Procedural justice | Fairness of the process — consistency, bias suppression, accuracy, correctability, representativeness (voice), ethicality (Leventhal's rules) | Thibaut and Walker; Leventhal (1980); Greenberg coined 'organisational justice' (1987) |
| Interactional justice | Fairness of treatment — interpersonal (dignity, respect) and informational (explanations, honesty) | Bies and Moag (1986); Colquitt's four-factor measure (2001) |
| Whistle blowing | Disclosure by a member of illegal, immoral or illegitimate practices under the employer's control to persons or organisations able to act (Near and Miceli); internal or external; the dilemma between loyalty and duty | Whistle Blowers Protection Act 2014 (public servants; complaints to the CVC); Companies Act 2013 s. 177(9) vigil mechanism for listed and prescribed companies; SEBI LODR whistle-blower policy; SEBI's informant mechanism for insider trading (2019); Sarbanes-Oxley in the US; Satyam (2009) and the Ranbaxy case as Indian illustrations |
3. HRM: concept, perspectives, influences, trends; HR planning, recruitment, selection, induction, training and development
Human resource management is the process of acquiring, developing, motivating and retaining people so that the organisation and its members achieve their goals — Armstrong's strategic and coherent approach to the management of the organisation's most valued assets. It grew from welfare officers (Rowntree, Cadbury, and in India the Factories Act welfare officer), through personnel management (record-keeping and industrial relations, reactive, staff-driven) to HRM (proactive, integrated with strategy, line-driven, treating people as assets) and now human capital and talent management. The perspectives are hard HRM (people as a resource to be deployed for profit — the Michigan matching model of Fombrun, Tichy and Devanna, with selection, appraisal, rewards and development fitting strategy) and soft HRM (people as valued partners — the Harvard model of Beer and colleagues, with stakeholder interests and situational factors shaping HR policy choices toward commitment, competence, congruence and cost-effectiveness); Guest's model and Storey's 27 points of difference complete the set. Influences on HRM are economic (growth, labour markets), technological, legal (labour codes), social and demographic (a young workforce, women's participation, ageing in other countries), political and cultural, and the strategy and structure of the firm itself. Recent trends: strategic HR and the HR business partner, HR analytics and people analytics, HR technology (HRIS, AI in recruitment, learning platforms), the gig and platform workforce, remote and hybrid work after 2020, employee experience and wellbeing, diversity and inclusion, agile HR, skills-based organisations, and India's four labour codes of 2019–20, in force from 21 November 2025, with their central and state rules being notified in stages.
| Stage | What it is | Methods and terms the paper asks |
|---|---|---|
| Human resource planning | Forecasting demand for and supply of people and reconciling them — the right number and kind at the right time and place | Demand: managerial judgement, ratio-trend, work-study, regression, Delphi, Markov analysis; supply: skills inventory, management inventory, replacement charts, succession plans, Markov flows, labour-market analysis; gap closed by recruitment, training, redeployment, overtime, contract labour, or by VRS, layoffs, attrition, redundancy; Vetter's definition; macro versus micro planning |
| Recruitment | Generating a pool of qualified applicants — a positive process; Flippo's 'searching for prospective employees and stimulating them to apply' | Internal (promotion, transfer, job posting, employee referrals, former employees) versus external (advertising, campus, employment exchanges, agencies, e-recruitment and job portals, social media, walk-ins, poaching); yield ratio and time-lapse data; realistic job preview; employer branding; the Employment Exchanges (Compulsory Notification of Vacancies) Act 1959 |
| Selection | Choosing from the pool — a negative process of rejection; matching the candidate to the job specification | Steps: application blank, screening, tests (aptitude, achievement, intelligence, personality, interest, situational judgement, work sample, assessment centre — in-basket, leaderless group discussion), interviews (structured, unstructured, stress, panel, behavioural, situational, group), reference checks, medical, final offer; reliability (consistency) versus validity (measures what it should — content, criterion: predictive and concurrent, construct); halo, contrast and similarity errors; false positives and negatives |
| Placement and induction (orientation) | Assigning the selected person to a job; introducing the newcomer to the organisation, the job and colleagues | Formal and informal induction; the buddy system; reduces reality shock and early turnover; socialisation stages; probation and confirmation |
| Training and development | Training is short-term, job-specific skill building for non-managers; development is long-term growth of managers; education is general | Process: needs assessment (organisational, task, person analysis), objectives, design, delivery, evaluation; on-the-job — coaching, mentoring, job rotation, apprenticeship, understudy, committee assignments, JIT; off-the-job — lectures, case study, role play, in-basket, business games, simulation, sensitivity training, programmed and e-learning, vestibule training; Kirkpatrick's four levels — reaction, learning, behaviour, results — and Phillips's fifth, return on investment; the Apprentices Act 1961; learning curve and transfer of training |
4. Job analysis, job evaluation and compensation management
Job analysis is the systematic study of a job to determine its tasks, duties, responsibilities and the knowledge, skills and abilities it needs. Its two products are the job description (what the job is — title, duties, working conditions, reporting relationships, tools) and the job specification (what the holder must be — qualifications, experience, skills, physical and personality requirements). Methods of collection are observation, interview, questionnaire — the Position Analysis Questionnaire of McCormick with its 194 items, Functional Job Analysis of Fine with its data-people-things hierarchy, the critical incident technique of Flanagan, diaries and logs, and the US Department of Labor's O*NET. Job analysis feeds HR planning, recruitment and selection, training, appraisal, job evaluation and job design. Job design decides how tasks are combined into jobs: job simplification (Taylor), job rotation, job enlargement (horizontal loading — more tasks at the same level), job enrichment (vertical loading — Herzberg, adding planning and control), and the Hackman-Oldham job characteristics model whose five core dimensions produce the critical psychological states of experienced meaningfulness, responsibility and knowledge of results; flexitime, job sharing, telecommuting and compressed weeks are the scheduling redesigns.
| Method | Type | How it works | Merit and limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ranking | Non-quantitative, whole-job | Jobs ordered from most to least valuable, often by paired comparison | Simple and cheap; subjective, no measure of distance between ranks; small firms |
| Classification or grading | Non-quantitative, whole-job | Grades defined first, jobs slotted into them | Used by governments (the Indian pay-commission grades); broad and rigid |
| Point rating | Quantitative, factor-based | Compensable factors (skill, effort, responsibility, working conditions) split into degrees with points; the job's total points set its grade | Most widely used; consistent and defensible; costly to install; the Hay Guide Chart-Profile method (know-how, problem solving, accountability) is its best-known proprietary form |
| Factor comparison | Quantitative, factor-based | Benchmark jobs ranked factor by factor and their pay apportioned among factors, giving a money scale on which other jobs are placed | Benge, Burk and Hay (1926); yields a wage directly; complex, and ties evaluation to existing pay |
Compensation is everything an employee receives in return for work: direct financial (basic pay, dearness allowance, incentives, bonus, commission), indirect financial (benefits — provident fund, gratuity, insurance, leave, housing) and non-financial (recognition, growth, work environment). The wage theories the paper names are the subsistence theory (Ricardo — the iron law), the wages fund theory (Adam Smith, Mill), the residual claimant theory (Walker), the marginal productivity theory (Clark, Marshall), the bargaining theory (Davidson) and the behavioural theories that tie pay to equity and expectancy. Wage concepts: minimum wage (bare subsistence plus efficiency), fair wage (between minimum and living, tied to capacity to pay — the Committee on Fair Wages, 1948) and living wage (comfort and provision for the future); nominal versus real wage; time rate versus piece rate, and incentive plans — Halsey and Rowan premium plans, Taylor's differential piece rate, Gantt task and bonus, Emerson efficiency, Bedaux point, Scanlon and Rucker gain-sharing, profit-sharing, employee stock options. Compensation management designs the structure through job evaluation (internal equity), wage surveys (external competitiveness), pay grades and ranges, broadbanding, and the 3-P approach — pay for position, person and performance — with competency-based pay, skill-based pay, variable pay and executive compensation (Companies Act limits under Schedule V, SEBI's disclosure of the CEO-to-median ratio). Indian law: Minimum Wages Act 1948, Payment of Wages Act 1936, Payment of Bonus Act 1965 (8.33% minimum, 20% maximum), Equal Remuneration Act 1976 — all four subsumed by the Code on Wages 2019, in force from 21 November 2025, which also provides for a national floor wage fixed by the Centre; the Payment of Gratuity Act 1972 (15 days' wages per year after five years); the Employees' Provident Funds Act 1952 (12% each from employer and employee); dearness allowance linked to the CPI for industrial workers.
Key takeaways
- Schein's three levels are artefacts, espoused values and basic assumptions; Handy's four cultures are power, role, task and person; climate is the measurable, changeable perception, culture the deep, slow substance.
- Hofstede's original four dimensions are power distance, individualism, masculinity and uncertainty avoidance, with long-term orientation and indulgence added later; India is high on power distance; Trompenaars has seven, GLOBE nine.
- Selye's GAS is alarm, resistance, exhaustion; Goleman's EI has five components; Maslach's burnout three dimensions; justice is distributive, procedural and interactional; the Whistle Blowers Protection Act is 2014 and the Companies Act vigil mechanism is section 177.
- Hard HRM is the Michigan matching model, soft HRM the Harvard model; recruitment is positive and selection negative; reliability is consistency, validity is measuring what it should; Kirkpatrick's levels are reaction, learning, behaviour, results.
- Job analysis yields the description and specification; job evaluation ranks jobs (ranking, classification, points, factor comparison — points most used) never people; enlargement is horizontal and enrichment vertical loading; the Code on Wages 2019 subsumes the Minimum Wages, Payment of Wages, Bonus and Equal Remuneration Acts.
Practice questions (9)
Attempt each one before opening the answer. Every explanation names the tempting wrong option as well as the right one, because that is where marks are lost.
In Edgar Schein's model of organisational culture, the deepest and least visible level consists of:
Show answer
Answer: A — Basic underlying assumptions
Artefacts are visible, espoused values are stated, and basic assumptions are unconscious and taken for granted — the level that actually drives behaviour and is hardest to change. Rituals are artefacts.Which of the following was NOT among Hofstede's original four dimensions of national culture?
Show answer
Answer: A — Long-term versus short-term orientation
The 1980 IBM study yielded power distance, individualism-collectivism, masculinity-femininity and uncertainty avoidance. Long-term orientation was added from Bond's Chinese Values Survey (1991) and indulgence-restraint with Minkov (2010).Hans Selye's general adaptation syndrome describes the body's response to stress in three stages:
Show answer
Answer: A — Alarm, resistance, exhaustion
Alarm mobilises, resistance copes, and exhaustion follows if the stressor persists. Unfreezing-changing-refreezing is Lewin's change model, forming-storming-norming is Tuckman, and denial-anger-acceptance belongs to Kübler-Ross.The fairness of the process used to arrive at a pay or promotion decision — its consistency, freedom from bias and opportunity for voice — is called:
Show answer
Answer: A — Procedural justice
Procedural justice (Leventhal's rules) concerns how the decision was made; distributive justice concerns the fairness of the outcome itself; interactional justice concerns the dignity and explanations given to the person. Restorative justice is a criminal-law concept.The 'matching model' of HRM, which fits selection, appraisal, rewards and development to business strategy and is associated with 'hard' HRM, comes from:
Show answer
Answer: A — The Michigan school (Fombrun, Tichy and Devanna)
The Michigan model (1984) is the hard, strategy-driven view. Harvard's map of HRM territory (1984) is the soft, stakeholder view aiming at commitment, competence, congruence and cost-effectiveness; Guest's model bridges the two; Ulrich describes HR roles.Recruitment is described as a positive process and selection as a negative process because:
Show answer
Answer: A — Recruitment seeks to attract as many suitable applicants as possible, while selection rejects the unsuitable
Recruitment builds the pool (Flippo's 'stimulating them to apply'); selection screens the pool down by eliminating candidates at each step. Recruitment precedes selection and both may use internal or external sources.In Kirkpatrick's model of training evaluation, the level that measures whether trainees actually apply what they learned on the job is:
Show answer
Answer: A — Level 3 — behaviour
Reaction asks whether trainees liked it, learning whether they acquired knowledge or skill, behaviour whether they transfer it to the job, and results whether the organisation gained. Phillips adds a fifth level, return on investment.Adding planning and control responsibilities to a job so that the holder gains autonomy and growth — 'vertical loading' — is called:
Show answer
Answer: A — Job enrichment
Enrichment (Herzberg) loads vertically; enlargement loads horizontally by adding more tasks at the same level; rotation moves the person between jobs; simplification (Taylor) breaks the job into narrower tasks.Which job evaluation method assigns points to degrees of compensable factors such as skill, effort, responsibility and working conditions, and is the most widely used?
Show answer
Answer: A — Point rating method
Point rating is quantitative and factor-based, producing a total score that places the job in a grade; the Hay method is its best-known form. Ranking and classification are whole-job, non-quantitative methods; factor comparison is quantitative but yields a money value directly from benchmark jobs.