Reporting and Editing I: News Concepts, Determinants and Values, Structure and Perspectives; Reporting for Print, Radio, Television and Digital Media; Types of Reporting; National and International News Agencies and Feature Syndicates; Writing for Each Medium; and Translation and Transcreation

The third unit is the craft of journalism, and nothing else on this platform teaches it. This chapter takes its first two items: what news is, what makes an event newsworthy, how a news story is structured and from what perspectives it can be written; how reporting differs for print, radio, television and digital media; the main types of reporting; the national and international news agencies and feature syndicates, their functions and role; writing for print, electronic and digital news media; and translation and transcreation, which in a multilingual country are part of every newsroom's daily work. Chapter 7 continues with editing, ethics, the critique of Western news values and niche reporting.

1. News: concepts and perspectives

News is a timely account of an event, development or idea that is new, significant or interesting to a public. Every definition stresses novelty and interest, and the old newsroom saying attributed to the New York Sun, that when a dog bites a man it is not news but when a man bites a dog it is, captures the element of the unusual. Sociologists add that news is not simply found but made. Gaye Tuchman's Making News (1978) described news as a frame, a window whose size and placement decide what can be seen, and showed how routines such as beats, deadlines and reliance on official sources shape what becomes news.

News can be written from several perspectives. Objective reporting presents facts with attribution and without the reporter's opinion; it grew in the nineteenth century with wire agencies that sold the same copy to papers of every political colour. Interpretative reporting explains the background and meaning of events. Investigative reporting uncovers what someone wants hidden. Development reporting, discussed in Chapter 4, examines programmes from the point of view of those they affect. Advocacy journalism openly takes a side. Most working journalism combines objective reporting of events with interpretation in context.

2. Determinants of news: news values

Newsroom practice lists the classic news values: timeliness, proximity (geographical and cultural), prominence of the people involved, consequence or impact, conflict, human interest, and novelty or unusualness. The most cited academic list is Johan Galtung and Mari Holmboe Ruge's "The Structure of Foreign News" (1965), a study of how Norwegian newspapers covered crises in the Congo, Cuba and Cyprus. They proposed twelve news factors: frequency (an event that fits the news cycle), threshold (size), unambiguity, meaningfulness (cultural proximity and relevance), consonance (fitting expectations), unexpectedness, continuity (a running story), composition (balance of the news mix), reference to elite nations, reference to elite persons, personification, and negativity. The more factors an event satisfies, the likelier it is to become news.

Tony Harcup and Deirdre O'Neill revisited the list against British newspapers in 2001 and again in 2017, when social media had changed selection. Their 2017 list includes exclusivity, bad news, conflict, surprise, audio-visuals, shareability, entertainment, drama, follow-up, the power elite, relevance, magnitude, celebrity, good news and the news organisation's own agenda. Shareability is the new factor: a story's chance of being spread on social platforms now influences whether it is covered and how it is packaged.

🧠 Galtung and Ruge: twelve, from 1965
Four of the twelve are "culture-bound" in their account: elite nations, elite persons, personification and negativity. These four are the ones later critics of Western news values attacked, as Chapter 7 shows.

3. The structure of a news story

The inverted pyramid puts the most important facts first and the least important last, so that a story can be cut from the bottom without losing its essentials and a reader who stops early still has the news. It is usually traced to the telegraph era of the nineteenth century, when correspondents sent the essentials first in case the line failed. The lead, or intro, answers as many as possible of the five Ws and one H: who, what, when, where, why and how. A summary lead does this directly; an anecdotal lead opens with a scene; a delayed lead withholds the main point for a sentence or two; a question lead or a quotation lead is used sparingly.

News story structures
StructureHow it worksTypical use
Inverted pyramidMost important first, in descending orderHard news, wire copy
HourglassSummary top, then a chronological narrativeCrime, disasters, court proceedings
Wall Street Journal formulaAnecdote, nut graf, body, and a return to the anecdoteFeatures and trend stories
ChronologicalEvents in the order they happenedNarrative features, some sports reports
Broadcast "tell-tell-tell"Tell what you will say, say it, repeat itRadio and television bulletins

The nut graf is the paragraph, usually second to fourth in a feature-style story, that states why the story matters now. Attribution tells the reader where each claim came from; quotations should add voice or evidence, not repeat what the reporter has already said. Sources are on the record (named), on background (used but not named), or off the record (not to be published), and an embargo is an agreement not to publish information before a set time, as with budgets and scientific papers.

4. Reporting across media, and types of reporting

Print allows depth, detail, figures and re-reading, so the print reporter can use complex sentences and data, though the discipline of the lead still applies. Radio is for the ear: one idea per sentence, conversational language, active voice, round numbers, attribution before the claim ("Police say three people died"), and no reliance on the listener remembering a name from an earlier sentence. Television writes to pictures: the words should add what the images cannot show, and the reporter's piece to camera (PTC), interviews (sound bites) and visuals must be planned together. Digital reporting is continuous and multimedia: breaking news goes out as alerts and live blogs, then is updated, linked, embedded with video, documents and social posts, and optimised so that search engines and readers can find it.

  • Beat reporting: a reporter covers a fixed area such as police, courts, municipal affairs, health or a ministry, and builds sources in it.
  • Investigative reporting: original, sustained inquiry into wrongdoing someone wants concealed, using documents, records and multiple sources.
  • Interpretative and in-depth reporting: background, analysis and context around an event.
  • Precision journalism: social-science methods such as surveys and statistics applied to reporting, named by Philip Meyer in Precision Journalism (1973); today's data journalism is its descendant.
  • Citizen journalism and explanatory journalism: reports by non-professionals, often via mobile phones, and pieces that explain complex subjects step by step.
⚠️ Investigative is not the same as interpretative
Interpretative reporting explains a known event; investigative reporting discovers something previously hidden, through the reporter's own inquiry. A story that analyses a published budget is interpretative, not investigative.

5. News agencies and feature syndicates

A news agency gathers news and sells it to subscribing newspapers, broadcasters and websites, which cannot keep correspondents everywhere. Agencies supply breaking news, photographs, video, data and features, and because they serve clients of every political view they developed the neutral, factual style of wire copy. A feature syndicate distributes non-news material, columns, cartoons, comic strips, puzzles and features, to many publications at once, as King Features Syndicate did in the United States from the 1910s and Project Syndicate does for opinion columns today. In India the Indian News and Feature Alliance (INFA), founded by the journalist Durga Das, was an early feature and news service.

Major news agencies
AgencyFoundedNotes
Havas / Agence France-Presse1835 / 1944Charles-Louis Havas's agency, the oldest; AFP succeeded it
Associated Press (AP)1846New York; a co-operative owned by member newspapers
Reuters1851Paul Julius Reuter, London; supplied India's early wire news
Xinhua1931China's state news agency
Press Trust of India (PTI)1947; operations from 1 February 1949Non-profit co-operative of newspapers; took over the Associated Press of India from Reuters
Hindustan Samachar1948Multilingual agency for Indian-language papers
United News of India (UNI)1961Second national agency; Hindi service Univarta
Asian News International (ANI) and IANS1971 and 1986Private agencies, ANI strong in video

India's first agency, the Associated Press of India, was founded by K. C. Roy in 1905 and later controlled by Reuters, which is why the Press Trust of India, formed by Indian newspapers, took it over when it began operations in 1949. During the Emergency the four national agencies, PTI, UNI, Hindustan Samachar and Samachar Bharati, were merged into one agency called Samachar in 1976; they were separated again in 1978.

6. Writing for each medium, and translation and transcreation

The shared rules of news writing are accuracy, brevity and clarity: short sentences, concrete nouns and active verbs, one idea per paragraph, attribution for every claim that is not common knowledge, and no adjectives that judge. Print can hold a sentence of twenty-five words; broadcast copy aims shorter, is read aloud to test it, spells out numbers and difficult names for the presenter, and avoids sentences that begin with a subordinate clause. Digital copy is scanned more than read: eye-tracking studies by the Nielsen Norman Group (2006) found an F-shaped pattern, so the key words go at the start of headings and paragraphs, text is broken by subheadings, and headlines state the news plainly so that they work in search results and social feeds.

Translation renders a text from one language into another, keeping its meaning as faithfully as possible. Indian newsrooms translate constantly: agency copy in English becomes a Hindi or Marathi story, a minister's Hindi speech becomes an English report, and errors in translating a quotation can change its meaning and create legal risk. Transcreation, a blend of translation and creation, recreates a message for a new language and culture, keeping its intent, tone and emotional effect rather than its words. It is used above all in advertising and campaign communication, where a slogan or joke that works in one language would fall flat or offend if translated word for word; a news report should be translated, while an advertising headline is usually transcreated.

🎯 Why a quotation is never transcreated
A quotation is evidence of what a person actually said. Reworking it for effect, which is what transcreation does, would put words in the speaker's mouth; a translated quotation must stay as close to the original as the target language allows, and the original should be kept on file.

Key takeaways

  • News is timely, new and significant, and is made through routines (Tuchman 1978); perspectives are objective, interpretative, investigative, development and advocacy.
  • News values: timeliness, proximity, prominence, impact, conflict, human interest, novelty; Galtung and Ruge's twelve factors (1965), including elite nations, elite persons, personification and negativity; Harcup and O'Neill (2001, 2017) added shareability.
  • Structure: inverted pyramid, lead with the five Ws and one H, hourglass, Wall Street Journal formula with its nut graf; sources on record, on background or off record; embargoes.
  • Media differ: print for depth, radio for the ear, television written to pictures with PTCs, digital continuous and multimedia; types include beat, investigative, interpretative, precision (Meyer 1973), data and citizen journalism.
  • Agencies: Havas 1835 (AFP 1944), AP 1846, Reuters 1851, Xinhua 1931; in India API 1905, PTI (operating from 1949), Hindustan Samachar 1948, UNI 1961, ANI 1971, IANS 1986, merged as Samachar in 1976; syndicates distribute columns and features; news is translated, advertising transcreated.

Practice questions (10)

Attempt each one before opening the answer. Every explanation names the tempting wrong option as well as the right one, because that is where marks are lost.

  1. "The Structure of Foreign News" (1965), which proposed a list of news factors, was written by:

    1. Johan Galtung and Mari Holmboe Ruge
    2. Bill Kovach and Tom Rosenstiel
    3. Tony Harcup and Deirdre O'Neill
    4. Edward Herman and Noam Chomsky
    Show answer

    Answer: A — Johan Galtung and Mari Holmboe Ruge

    Galtung and Ruge's 1965 study of Norwegian coverage of three foreign crises produced the twelve news factors. Harcup and O'Neill revised the list in 2001 and 2017; Kovach and Rosenstiel wrote The Elements of Journalism; Herman and Chomsky proposed the propaganda model.
  2. The inverted pyramid structure means that a news story:

    1. Begins with the reporter's opinion
    2. Builds up to a climax at the end
    3. Presents the most important facts first and less important details later
    4. Tells events strictly in the order they happened
    Show answer

    Answer: C — Presents the most important facts first and less important details later

    The inverted pyramid leads with the essentials so the story can be cut from the bottom. Building to a climax is the structure of fiction, strict time order is the chronological form, and opinion does not belong in a hard-news lead.
  3. Which of the following are Indian national news agencies? Select all that apply.

    1. Indo-Asian News Service
    2. United News of India
    3. Xinhua
    4. Press Trust of India
    Show answer

    Answer: A — Indo-Asian News Service; B — United News of India; D — Press Trust of India

    PTI, UNI and IANS are Indian agencies, founded or operating from 1949, 1961 and 1986. Xinhua is China's state news agency, founded in 1931.
  4. Reuters was founded in London in 1851 by:

    1. K. C. Roy
    2. Charles-Louis Havas
    3. Bernhard Wolff
    4. Paul Julius Reuter
    Show answer

    Answer: D — Paul Julius Reuter

    Paul Julius Reuter set up his agency in London in 1851. Havas founded the French agency in 1835, Bernhard Wolff the German agency in 1849, and K. C. Roy the Associated Press of India in 1905.
  5. Assertion (A): Radio news is written in short sentences in a conversational style, with attribution placed before the claim. Reason (R): A listener cannot go back and re-read a sentence that was missed or misunderstood. Choose the correct option.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A — Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A

    Both are true and R explains A: because radio is heard once, in sequence, sentences must be short, familiar in style and ordered so that the listener knows who is speaking before hearing what was said. Print readers can re-read, which is why print tolerates longer sentences.
  6. The use of social-science research methods such as surveys and statistical analysis in reporting was named "precision journalism" by:

    1. Gaye Tuchman
    2. David Manning White
    3. Walter Lippmann
    4. Philip Meyer
    Show answer

    Answer: D — Philip Meyer

    Philip Meyer's Precision Journalism (1973) argued that reporters should use the tools of social science; data journalism descends from it. Tuchman studied how news is made, Lippmann wrote Public Opinion (1922), and White did the gatekeeping study.
  7. How many news factors did Galtung and Ruge propose in their 1965 study? Type the number.

    Numerical answer — type the value.

    Show answer

    Answer: 12

    They proposed twelve: frequency, threshold, unambiguity, meaningfulness, consonance, unexpectedness, continuity, composition, elite nations, elite persons, personification and negativity.
  8. In a feature-style news story, the "nut graf" is the paragraph that:

    1. Ends the story with a twist
    2. Gives the byline and dateline
    3. States why the story matters now
    4. Contains only a direct quotation
    Show answer

    Answer: C — States why the story matters now

    The nut graf, usually after an anecdotal opening, explains the story's significance and justifies its place in the paper. The byline and dateline are credits, a closing twist is a kicker, and a paragraph of quotation alone is not the nut graf.
  9. Which of the following correctly describe transcreation? Select all that apply.

    1. It aims to preserve the intent, tone and emotional effect of the original
    2. It is the correct way to render a politician's quotation in a news report
    3. It adapts cultural references so that the message works in the target culture
    4. It requires strict word-for-word fidelity to the source
    Show answer

    Answer: A — It aims to preserve the intent, tone and emotional effect of the original; C — It adapts cultural references so that the message works in the target culture

    Transcreation recreates a message for a new culture, keeping its intent and effect rather than its words. Word-for-word fidelity describes literal translation, and a quotation in news must be translated faithfully, never transcreated, because it is evidence of what was said.
  10. When the Press Trust of India began operations in 1949, it took over:

    1. The news services of All India Radio
    2. The Associated Press of India, then controlled by Reuters
    3. The Indian operations of Agence France-Presse
    4. United News of India
    Show answer

    Answer: B — The Associated Press of India, then controlled by Reuters

    PTI took over the Associated Press of India, founded by K. C. Roy in 1905 and later controlled by Reuters, so that Indian newspapers would own their own agency. AFP's operations and AIR's news were never PTI's, and UNI was founded separately in 1961.