Early Medieval Religion, Society and the Debate on State Formation

Unit III's third and final chapter turns to religious change (temple-centred Brahminical Hinduism and the Tamil Bhakti saints), social structure (caste proliferation, women, tribes, untouchability), education, and the theoretical debate — feudal, segmentary or integrative — that the previous chapter deferred to here.

1. Brahminical Religion, Temples and the Bhakti Movement

Vaisnavism and Saivism grow into the period's two dominant sectarian traditions, each attracting royal patronage that translates directly into temple-building on a scale earlier periods had not seen — and temple architecture regionalises sharply into the styles the concepts list names: Nagara (a curvilinear tower, dominant across north and central India), Dravida (a stepped, pyramidal tower with a gateway gopuram, dominant in Tamil country under the Pallavas and Colas), and Vesara (a hybrid of the two, associated with the Deccan under the Chalukyas and Hoysalas).

  • Tamil Bhakti — the Alvars (Vaishnava poet-saints) and Nayanars (Saiva poet-saints) compose intensely emotional devotional hymns in Tamil from roughly the 6th-9th centuries, insisting personal, direct devotion (bhakti) to a chosen deity matters more than ritual or birth-status — a theological populism the later philosophical systematisers formalise.
  • Shankara, Madhava and Ramanujacharya — Shankara's Advaita (non-dualist) Vedanta, Ramanuja's Vishishtadvaita (qualified non-dualism, providing bhakti a philosophical grounding within Vaishnavism) and Madhava's Dvaita (strict dualism) are the three great philosophical schools the syllabus names, each reworking the Vedanta tradition differently while engaging directly with the devotional current the Alvars and Nayanars had already popularised.

2. Society: Varna, Jati, Women, Tribes and Untouchability

The four-fold varna order proliferates in this period into a far larger number of jatis (endogamous, occupation-linked sub-castes), driven partly by the incorporation of new occupational and craft groups thrown up by land-grant agriculture and expanding trade, and partly by the assimilation of tribal groups into the varna order at its lower end as agrarian expansion brought settled agriculture into forest and hill tracts previously outside it — a process the syllabus names directly as 'tribes as peasants and their place in the varna order'.

Position of women: continuity and change
DimensionDevelopment
Gender, marriage and propertyStridhana continues in theory to give women a limited independent property claim, but practices such as early marriage, restrictions on widow remarriage in higher castes, and dowry-adjacent gift customs increasingly constrain women's actual autonomy across this period.
Women in public lifeRoyal women occasionally hold real political power (queens acting as regents, temple patrons in their own right) and women poet-saints (among the Alvars, Andal is the best known) achieve a religious authority otherwise closed to women — exceptions that prove rather than erase the general constraint above.
⚠️ Untouchability is not the same claim as varna hierarchy
NET distinguishes a general varna/jati hierarchy (a graded ranking, in principle still 'within' the social order) from untouchability specifically (groups placed conceptually and physically OUTSIDE the fourfold varna order altogether, subject to distinct restrictions on contact, residence and access) — the syllabus lists the two as related but separate sub-items, and a question naming one should not be answered with evidence about the other.

3. Education and Educational Institutions

Three distinct institutional forms carried education in this period, and NET tests them as distinct rather than as one generic 'ancient education system': Agraharas were Brahmana settlements granted by royal charter that functioned simultaneously as centres of Vedic and Sanskrit learning; Mathas were monastic institutions attached to a particular philosophical/sectarian lineage (Shankara's own four cardinal mathas are the best-known example) combining religious training with broader instruction; and Mahaviharas were large Buddhist monastic universities (Nalanda, and Vallabhi in the west) that drew students and teachers from across Asia and taught a far wider curriculum than religious doctrine alone, including logic, medicine and grammar.

ℹ️ Growth of regional languages
The Bhakti hymns' composition directly IN regional languages (Tamil for the Alvars/Nayanars, and gradually Kannada, Telugu and other regional literatures maturing alongside continuing Sanskrit scholarship) is the syllabus's own named development — a Sanskrit-versus-regional-language relationship that runs in parallel with, and partly explains, the religious populism of the Bhakti movement itself.

4. The Debate on State Formation: Feudal, Segmentary, Integrative

The syllabus names this debate explicitly as three lettered models, and NET tests the name-to-content match precisely:
(A) the Feudal model (R.S. Sharma's most influential formulation) reads land grants as creating a hierarchy of intermediaries between king and peasant that structurally parallels European feudalism, with declining trade and coinage cited as corroborating evidence of a more agrarian, closed economy;
(B) the Segmentary model (Burton Stein, drawing on African anthropology, applied chiefly to the Cola state) argues that real administrative power actually shrank sharply outside the core 'nuclear' zone even while RITUAL sovereignty — ceremonial recognition of the king's overlordship — extended much further, so the state was strong ritually but weak administratively at its edges;
(C) the Integrative model (associated with B.D. Chattopadhyaya and Hermann Kulke) rejects both as too focused on decline or weakness, arguing instead that local, pre-state structures (peasant communities, samantas, local cults) were being progressively drawn into and integrated with a larger regional political and cultural order — state formation as an ongoing constructive process, not a story of fragmentation from an earlier centralised ideal.

The three models, side by side
ModelKey claim and association
A. FeudalLand grants create subinfeudation hierarchies; declining trade/coinage corroborates a closed agrarian economy — R.S. Sharma.
B. SegmentaryReal power shrinks outside the core zone even as ritual sovereignty extends further — Burton Stein, on the Cola state.
C. IntegrativeLocal pre-state structures are progressively drawn into a larger order — a constructive process, not decline — Chattopadhyaya and Kulke.

Key takeaways

  • Temple architecture regionalises into Nagara (north), Dravida (south, Pallava-Cola) and Vesara (Deccan hybrid); the Alvars and Nayanars pioneer Tamil Bhakti, formalised philosophically by Shankara (Advaita), Ramanuja (Vishishtadvaita) and Madhava (Dvaita).
  • Varna proliferates into jatis via new occupational groups and tribal assimilation; stridhana's theoretical protection coexists with tightening practical constraints on women, though exceptional women (regents, Andal) hold real power/authority.
  • Untouchability (groups placed outside the varna order) is a distinct claim from general varna/jati hierarchy (a ranking within it).
  • Agraharas, Mathas and Mahaviharas are three distinct educational institutions (Brahmana-charter settlements, sectarian monasteries, Buddhist monastic universities like Nalanda), alongside growth of regional languages (Tamil and others) beside Sanskrit.
  • The state-formation debate names three models by letter: Feudal (Sharma), Segmentary (Stein, on the Colas) and Integrative (Chattopadhyaya/Kulke) — each a different account of the same land-grant-based, decentralised political order.

Practice questions (9)

Attempt each one before opening the answer. Every explanation names the tempting wrong option as well as the right one, because that is where marks are lost.

  1. The Dravida temple style, marked by a stepped pyramidal tower and gopuram gateway, is chiefly associated with:

    1. The Pallavas and Colas in Tamil country
    2. North and central India
    3. The Deccan Chalukyas and Hoysalas
    4. Bengal under the Palas
    Show answer

    Answer: A — The Pallavas and Colas in Tamil country

    Dravida is the south Indian, Tamil-country style under the Pallavas and Colas; Nagara belongs to the north/centre and Vesara to the Deccan hybrid.
  2. Ramanuja's philosophical school, providing bhakti a grounding within Vaishnavism, is called:

    1. Vishishtadvaita (qualified non-dualism)
    2. Advaita (non-dualism)
    3. Dvaita (dualism)
    4. Niyati (determinism)
    Show answer

    Answer: A — Vishishtadvaita (qualified non-dualism)

    Ramanuja's Vishishtadvaita is qualified non-dualism; Shankara's is Advaita (strict non-dualism) and Madhava's is Dvaita (strict dualism); niyati is the unrelated Ajivika doctrine.
  3. Untouchability, as distinguished by NET from general varna/jati hierarchy, refers specifically to:

    1. Groups placed conceptually and physically outside the fourfold varna order
    2. Any ranking within the varna order
    3. The position of Kshatriyas relative to Brahmanas
    4. A regional temple-building style
    Show answer

    Answer: A — Groups placed conceptually and physically outside the fourfold varna order

    Untouchability names groups placed outside the varna order altogether with distinct restrictions, a different claim from a graded ranking within the order.
  4. A Mahavihara such as Nalanda is best described as:

    1. A large Buddhist monastic university with a broad curriculum
    2. A Brahmana-settlement land grant
    3. A Sufi shrine
    4. A merchant guild-hall
    Show answer

    Answer: A — A large Buddhist monastic university with a broad curriculum

    Mahaviharas were large Buddhist monastic universities teaching a wide curriculum, distinct from agraharas (Brahmana land-grant settlements) and mathas (sectarian monasteries).
  5. R.S. Sharma's Feudal model of early medieval state formation cites which as corroborating evidence?

    1. Declining trade and coinage indicating a closed agrarian economy
    2. Rising overseas trade with Southeast Asia
    3. A written democratic constitution
    4. The Fourth Buddhist Council
    Show answer

    Answer: A — Declining trade and coinage indicating a closed agrarian economy

    Sharma's Feudal model reads declining trade and coinage as corroborating a more closed, agrarian, subinfeudated economy — a claim the Integrative and Segmentary models each dispute in different ways.
  6. Burton Stein's Segmentary model, applied chiefly to which state, argues that ritual sovereignty extended further than real administrative power?

    1. The Cola state
    2. The Gupta empire
    3. The Delhi Sultanate
    4. The Maurya empire
    Show answer

    Answer: A — The Cola state

    Stein developed the segmentary model specifically for the Cola state, arguing real power shrank sharply outside its core zone even as ceremonial recognition of overlordship extended further.
  7. The Integrative model, associated with Chattopadhyaya and Kulke, characterises early medieval state formation as:

    1. A constructive process integrating local structures into a larger order
    2. A story of decline from an earlier centralised ideal
    3. Purely ritual sovereignty with no administrative content
    4. A hierarchy of land-grant-based subinfeudation alone
    Show answer

    Answer: A — A constructive process integrating local structures into a larger order

    The Integrative model rejects both the feudal and segmentary readings as too focused on decline/weakness, framing state formation instead as an ongoing constructive integration of local structures.
  8. Which of the following are correctly paired — model and its principal association?

    1. Feudal — R.S. Sharma
    2. Segmentary — Burton Stein
    3. Integrative — Chattopadhyaya and Kulke
    4. Feudal — Burton Stein
    Show answer

    Answer: A — Feudal — R.S. Sharma; B — Segmentary — Burton Stein; C — Integrative — Chattopadhyaya and Kulke

    Sharma is associated with the Feudal model, Stein with the Segmentary model (on the Colas), and Chattopadhyaya/Kulke with the Integrative model — the fourth pairing swaps Stein into the wrong model.
  9. Name the best-known woman poet-saint among the Alvars, whose Tamil hymns achieved a religious authority otherwise closed to women.

    Numerical answer — type the value.

    Show answer

    Answer: Andal

    Andal, among the twelve Alvars, is the best-known woman poet-saint of Tamil Vaishnava Bhakti, cited as an exception to the period's general constraints on women's public/religious authority.